Set a Watch

I’ve never played a co-op game that makes me feel like every roll of the dice really matters—the resource management is tight and keeps everyone engaged. It’s challenging but satisfying to figure out how to hold off the Unhallowed with just a few dice each round.

Didn't expect a co-op puzzle to get this tense — we spent a solid twenty minutes just deciding who guards which watch. The 1-4 player scaling actually works, though two of us found it the sweet spot.

Played this with three friends and the turn order puzzle kept everyone arguing in a good way. The difficulty ramps up fast in the later nights, which nearly knocked it down to three stars for us. Still, the Unhallowed theme and the light-management tension make it worth the table space.